Foodie Pundit

Campbell's Soup Is In Hot Water Over Alleged Off-The-Clock Labor Scams

A proposed class action claims the soup giant and its staffing firm partner bypassed overtime laws, signaling a major shift in how the food industry must treat

By Foodie Pundit Newsroom - Published - Updated - Section: Policy Regulation

Campbell's Soup Is In Hot Water Over Alleged Off-The-Clock Labor Scams

Key points

  • Campbell’s and CorTech LLC face allegations of failing to pay overtime to hourly contingent workers for nights and weekends.
  • The lawsuit argues that the use of a staffing agency does not shield major food brands from joint employer liability.
  • The legal push mirrors historic accountability shifts seen in other industries, moving toward a more holistic view of labor rights.

A massive legal storm is brewing over one of the most iconic names in the American pantry. The Campbell's Co., formerly known as the Campbell Soup Company, is facing a high stakes lawsuit that strikes at the heart of how modern food giants manage their labor. Filed in a New Jersey federal court, the proposed class and collective action alleges that Campbell's and its staffing partner, CorTech LLC, systematically stiffed hourly workers out of their hard earned overtime pay.

This is not just a minor clerical error or a one time glitch in the payroll system. The lawsuit paints a picture of a calculated operational strategy where contingent workers were allegedly required to put in hours during nights and weekends without the time and a half compensation required by law. For a generation of foodies and industry professionals who value transparency and fair labor practices, this case is a wake up call about the "gigification" of the food manufacturing supply chain.

At its core, the lawsuit alleges violations of both the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and New Jersey state wage laws. The FLSA is the bedrock of American labor law, established to ensure that if you work more than 40 hours in a week, you get paid for that extra effort. When a company the size of Campbell's is accused of bypassing these rules through the use of a third party staffing firm, it raises massive questions about corporate accountability and the ethics of the modern "contingent" workforce. Who Is On The Hook

The defendants in this case represent two very different but equally critical parts of the food industry machinery. On one side, you have The Campbell's Co. This is a brand that has been a staple of American culture for over 150 years. From Andy Warhol's pop art to the red and white cans sitting in nearly every kitchen cabinet, Campbell's is a titan.

They do not just make soup anymore, they own brands like Goldfish, Pepperidge Farm, and Snyder's of Hanover. When a brand this large is named in a wage theft suit, the reputational risk is astronomical.

On the other side of the "hook" is CorTech LLC. CorTech is a global staffing and recruiting firm that provides "flexible" labor solutions to large corporations. In the food industry, companies like Campbell's often rely on firms like CorTech to fill their factories and warehouses with workers who are technically employees of the staffing agency, not the food company itself. This arrangement is often referred to as a "joint employer" relationship, and it is a legal minefield.

The lawsuit argues that both Campbell's and CorTech are responsible for the unpaid wages. By naming both, the plaintiffs are attempting to pierce the corporate veil that often allows big brands to distance themselves from the labor practices of their contractors. For the workers, it does not matter whose name is on the paycheck if the hours worked are not being paid correctly. So what Campbell's did

The nitty gritty of the complaint is where things get truly messy. According to the filing, hourly contingent workers were frequently expected to work outside of their scheduled shifts. This included staying late on weekdays, coming in on weekends, and working through the night to meet production quotas or handle administrative tasks that could not be completed during the day.

The plaintiffs allege that Campbell's and CorTech had a "policy or practice" of failing to record these extra hours. In the world of industrial food production, every minute counts. If a production line is running behind, workers are often pressured to stay until the job is done. The lawsuit claims that despite these long hours, the workers' paychecks reflected only their standard hours, effectively erasing the overtime they earned.

What makes this particularly spicy is the claim that this happened with the full knowledge of management. In many FLSA cases, companies try to argue that they had no idea workers were staying late. However, the plaintiffs suggest that the culture of the workplace necessitated this "off the clock" labor. If you are told you have to finish a pallet before you leave, but the clock stops at 5:00 PM, that is a direct path to a lawsuit. Financial Fallout

The financial implications here are staggering. Because this is a "class and collective action," it is not just about the one or two people who filed the suit. It is about every single hourly contingent worker who was placed at Campbell's by CorTech over a specific period. We are potentially talking about hundreds, if not thousands, of workers.

Under the FLSA, if a company is found to have willfully violated overtime laws, they can be held liable for "liquidated damages." This is legal speak for double pay. The court can order the company to pay the back wages plus an equal amount as a penalty. When you add in the legal fees for both sides, which the defendant usually has to pay if they lose, the price tag for "saving" money on overtime starts to look like a very bad investment.

For Campbell's, a company that is currently navigating a rebrand and trying to appeal to younger, more socially conscious consumers, the brand damage might even outweigh the cash settlement. Gen Z and Millennial consumers are increasingly making purchasing decisions based on how companies treat their workers. A "wage theft" headline is a direct hit to the brand equity that Campbell's has spent millions to build. Big Tobacco Parallels

You might wonder what soup has to do with cigarettes, but the legal strategy here bears a striking resemblance to the tactics used against Big Tobacco decades ago. For years, tobacco companies used complex corporate structures and third party distributors to insulate themselves from the health consequences of their products. They argued that they were simply manufacturers and not responsible for how the product reached consumers or what happened after it left the factory.

Similarly, large food corporations have increasingly used staffing agencies as a buffer. By claiming that workers are "contractors" or "employees of CorTech," companies like Campbell's have historically tried to wash their hands of labor disputes. However, just as the courts eventually held Big Tobacco responsible for the "holistic" impact of their business model, labor courts are increasingly looking at the "economic reality" of the workplace.

If Campbell's sets the hours, provides the equipment, and supervises the work, the law increasingly says they are the employer, regardless of what the contract with the staffing agency says. This shift is a direct challenge to the "arms length" labor model that has dominated the food industry for the last twenty years. How this screws small places

While Campbell's is a manufacturing giant, the ripples of this case will be felt in every local bistro and independent cafe. If you are a restaurant owner, you might think "I don't have a staffing agency, this doesn't apply to me." But the core issue is the same: the management of hourly labor and the temptation to have people "help out" off the clock.

Independent restaurants are currently facing a massive labor shortage and skyrocketing costs. The pressure to ask a loyal server to "just finish those side duties" or stay an extra thirty minutes to close up without logging it in the POS system is immense. However, this lawsuit shows that the legal system is becoming much more aggressive in pursuing these "small" infractions.

For local foodies, this case is a reminder to look behind the curtain. The "Great Resignation" in the hospitality industry was fueled by the same frustrations alleged in this lawsuit: a feeling that the labor of the worker is being undervalued and exploited. When a giant like Campbell's gets hit, it sets a precedent that makes it easier for workers at smaller establishments to seek legal recourse for similar issues. It reinforces the idea that "fair pay for fair work"

Sources and methodology

Reported from the public datasets below.

All sources Foodie Pundit reports from

More from the Foodie Pundit Newsroom

Permalink