A Witchy New Restaurant Is Coming to Washington Circle
A celebrated local operator is bringing a new concept to the former Marcel's space.
By Foodie Pundit Newsroom - Published - Updated - Section: Restaurant Openings

Key points
- The operator, Elli Ben-_Benchimol_, has a proven track record with successful D.C. concepts Apéro and La Bohème.
- The restaurant is taking over the former Marcel's space near Washington Circle, a location with a long history of fine dining.
- The name, meaning "Elizabeth the Witch" in Italian, suggests a concept rooted in Italian cuisine and folklore, possibly with a theatrical flair.
- The specific style of Italian cuisine and the interpretation of the "Strega" theme remain the biggest unanswered questions.
A new concept is brewing in the heart of Foggy Bottom, and its details are as enigmatic and alluring as its name. Ellizabetta La Strega, which translates from Italian to "Elizabeth the Witch," is slated to take over the prestigious address once occupied by the celebrated fine-dining institution Marcel's, a stone's throw from Washington Circle. The project comes from Elli Benchimol, a name that should immediately signal quality and thoughtful execution to local diners familiar with the chic European stylings of Apéro and the breezy, transportive atmosphere of La Bohème.
With such a respected operator at the helm, the announcement, though sparse on concrete details, has already sent ripples of anticipation through the city's deeply engaged food scene. The name itself evokes a sense of mystique, old-world charm, and perhaps a hint of the theatrical, promising a concept deeply rooted in a strong narrative. Washington is a city that thrives on power and policy, but it loves a good story, and a restaurant named "the Witch" arriving in a corridor of institutional influence is a compelling opening chapter.
The intelligence trail for this project begins with a single, potent piece of evidence: a media mention from August 6, 2026. In the world of opening intelligence, a media mention is a specific type of signal. It's not a leaked document or a bureaucratic filing; it is a controlled, deliberate announcement from an operator to the public.
This confirms that Ellizabetta La Strega is the next venture from Elli Benchimol and that it is moving from the idea phase into a concrete, forthcoming project. This signal establishes the foundational facts and sets the public narrative.
The location is confirmed as the former Marcel's space at 2401 Pennsylvania Avenue NW. This address is not just a set of coordinates; it carries a significant legacy and a set of built-in expectations. For nearly two decades, under the stewardship of Chef Robert Wiedmaier, Marcel's was a bastion of sophisticated French and Belgian cuisine.
It was a special occasion destination, a place of power lunches and anniversary dinners that helped define elegant, formal dining in the District. That a seasoned and successful operator like Benchimol has secured this specific piece of real estate suggests a project of significant ambition and confidence. The closure of Marcel's in 2020 left a tangible void in the neighborhood's high-end dining landscape, and industry watchers have been keenly observing what might be deemed worthy of such an iconic location.
The choice of this space for Ellizabetta La Strega immediately frames it as a serious play for a discerning clientele, one that appreciates both history and forward-thinking innovation. It signals this is not intended to be a casual pop-up but a potential new anchor for the West End.
The name itself, "Ellizabetta La Strega," is the most significant clue and the most tantalizing enigma. Its Italian origin is the strongest indicator we have for the culinary focus. But it's the second part, "La Strega" or "the Witch," that adds a fascinating layer of folklore and mystique.
This could point to a thematic element in the decor, a specific regional inspiration tied to Italian witchcraft legends, or simply a desire to create a memorable and evocative brand that stands out in a crowded market. The evidence at hand is limited but powerful. We have a respected operator, a legendary location, and a name that sparks the imagination.
To truly understand the potential of Ellizabetta La Strega, one must look at the established track record of its creator, Elli Benchimol. Her existing establishments, Apéro and La Bohème, are not merely restaurants; they are carefully curated experiences that have captured the affection of Washington diners by delivering distinct, immersive worlds.
Apéro, tucked away in Georgetown, is a sophisticated yet unstuffy wine bar that feels like a chic Parisian discovery. Its name, a nod to the French tradition of the apéritif, perfectly encapsulates its mission: to provide a relaxed, convivial setting for pre-dinner drinks and refined snacks. With its intimate, candlelit ambiance, a thoughtfully selected and often surprising wine list, and a menu of small plates that are elegant but not fussy, Apéro has become a go-to for those seeking a touch of European grace. It demonstrates Benchimol's talent for creating atmosphere, her deep understanding of how to pair food and drink, and her ability to make sophistication feel accessible and warm.
Then there is La Bohème, a venture that showcases a different, more effervescent facet of her hospitality vision. Located in the historically eclectic Adams Morgan, this restaurant, with its vibrant, bohemian-inspired decor and a menu that travels the sunny shores of the Mediterranean, feels like an instant vacation. It is a restaurant that prioritizes vibe and a transportive quality, proving that Benchimol can execute not just on quiet sophistication but also on lively, energetic dining that feels like a perpetual party. It's a testament to her ability to build a brand that is as much about feeling as it is about flavor.
The common thread between Apéro and La Bohème is a clear, confident, and deeply personal point of view. They are not chasing fleeting trends but are instead built on a foundation of classic hospitality principles, masterfully updated for a modern audience. Benchimol has shown a deft hand at creating spaces that are both commercially successful and critically respected, cultivating a loyal following that trusts her taste.
This history is the strongest indicator of what we might expect from Ellizabetta La Strega. It suggests that the new restaurant will be far more than just a place to eat. It will be a fully realized concept, from the design of the room to the weight of the glassware, from the service style to the curated playlist.
Given the Italian name, it is logical to assume Benchimol will apply this same meticulous, world-building approach to the vast and varied landscape of Italian cuisine and culture. Her previous successes give her the credibility and the trust of the dining public, turning a simple announcement into a major event.
Foggy Bottom and the adjacent West End, the nexus where Ellizabetta La Strega will plant its flag, is a neighborhood of powerful contrasts and significant opportunity. This is a zone of global influence, home to George Washington University, the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, and a dense concentration of law firms, lobbying groups, and embassies. This geography provides a built-in, day-and-night clientele of students, academics, diplomats, and professionals with sophisticated palates and, often, generous expense accounts.
Despite this enviable demographic, the area has sometimes been perceived as a culinary gap, a somewhat staid zone between the historic charm of Georgetown and the ever-evolving restaurant rows of Dupont Circle and Downtown. The departure of Marcel's amplified this perception, creating an opening for a new standard-bearer, a destination restaurant that could redefine the neighborhood's dining identity. The immediate vicinity is not a wasteland; it includes established power-dining spots, many housed in luxury hotels, as well as casual student hangouts and quick-service chains. The growing number of upscale residential buildings adds another layer of demand from residents hungry for quality local options.
The proximity to the Kennedy Center also adds a crucial dynamic, creating a steady demand for pre-theater and post-performance dining that is both efficient and elegant. Ellizabetta La Strega is perfectly positioned to capitalize on all of these streams. It can serve as an intimate neighborhood boîte for the area's well-heeled residents, a convenient and impressive spot for business lunches and dinners, and a go-to destination for cultural patrons.
By taking over the Marcel's space, the restaurant inherits a mantle of prestige and a location already imprinted on the mental map of D.C. diners. The challenge, and the opportunity, will be to honor that legacy while forging a new and distinct identity that feels contemporary and exciting. The neighborhood is ready for a jolt of independent, concept-driven energy.
Based on the evidence and the operator's history, we can begin to sketch an analytical projection of the dining experience. While Marcel's was known for its formal, white-tablecloth approach, Benchimol's style at Apéro and La Bohème suggests something different. Diners should anticipate a space that prioritizes style and atmosphere, likely more energetic and social than its predecessor.
Expect a meticulously designed interior that fully commits to its theme, creating an immersive environment from the moment you walk in. A strong, thoughtful bar program is almost a certainty, given its central role at both of her existing venues.
Given the Italian name and the "Strega" reference, the menu will almost certainly be Italian. The question is, what kind? The name could be a direct clue pointing towards the region of Campania and the city of Benevento, known in antiquity as the "City of Witches" and the origin of the iconic yellow Strega liqueur.
This would suggest a menu focused on the vibrant, sun-drenched flavors of Southern Italy, a departure from the Northern Italian or Roman fare more common in D.C.'s high-end scene. This regional focus would align perfectly with the current national obsession with hyper-specific Italian cuisine.
Regarding price point, we can triangulate. The Pennsylvania Avenue address and the legacy of the space command a premium. However, Benchimol's existing concepts are positioned as "accessible luxury" rather than budget-breaking special occasion spots. It is reasonable to expect Ellizabetta La Strega to land in a similar zone: a price point that reflects high-quality ingredients and a prime location, placing it in the upper tier of D.C. dining but perhaps more approachable than the tasting-menu-driven formality of the former Marcel's.
With the initial announcement made, the project now enters a crucial development phase. For those tracking its progress, the next signals will come not from press releases but from the public record and the street. The primary question swirling around Ellizabetta La Strega remains the specifics of the concept.
Will the restaurant lean heavily into the "witch" theme in its decor and branding, perhaps with a dark, moody, and atmospheric space filled with herbal motifs? Or will the name be a more subtle reference to the "magic" of cooking?
The first and most critical milestone to watch for is the filing of an Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) license application with the city. This document is a treasure trove of information, officially confirming the restaurant's legal trade name, its parent corporate entity, and the names of the principals. It is the first formal, bureaucratic step and signals that the project is moving forward in earnest.
Following that, we will monitor for building and construction permits. The scope of these permits will tell a story. Are they for minor cosmetic updates, or for a full gut renovation?
The latter would suggest a more ambitious transformation and a longer timeline before opening. Soon after, we anticipate seeing online job postings. A search for an Executive Chef or General Manager is a major indicator that the leadership team is being assembled.
The language used in these job descriptions can also offer valuable clues about the desired culinary style, service standards, and overall restaurant culture. Finally, the simplest signs are often the most telling: paper going up over the windows at 2401 Pennsylvania Avenue, the registration of social media handles, and the first signs of construction crews on site. Each of these is a breadcrumb on the trail to opening night.
The pending arrival of Ellizabetta La Strega is more than just another opening on the D.C. calendar. It represents the intersection of a proven, visionary operator with a piece of iconic culinary real estate. Elli Benchimol has demonstrated a rare ability to create not just restaurants, but destinations with soul and a distinct point of view.
The choice of the former Marcel's space is a bold statement of intent, promising a concept worthy of the location's storied history. The evocative name hints at a transportive experience, one that blends Italian tradition with a touch of modern mystique. For the West End, it promises a new center of gravity, a potential anchor that could energize the entire neighborhood.
While many details remain shrouded in mystery, the known elements, the operator, the location, and the intriguing name, all point toward the development of one of the most anticipated and potentially significant restaurants in Washington's near future. This is one to watch.
Sources and methodology
Reported from the public datasets below.
More from the Foodie Pundit Newsroom
- Gut Health Drives Fermented Foods Into Mainstream Restaurant Menus
- Gordon Ramsay Reveals Operational Strategy While Expanding Hospitality Footprint
- The Economics of Alcohol-Free Brews as Sober Curious Movement Transforms Beverage Retail
- USDA bought Trident Seafoods $14.7M in frozen pollock: Your tax dollars at work in government food programs
- Florida Is Rolling With A New Handroll Hawker